State Budget Deliberations Must Be Open and Transparent

By John Brautigam, LWVME Board of Directors

Recently the Maine Freedom of Information Coalition wrote to the leaders of the Maine legislature regarding the process for consideration and approval of the state budget and other legislation.  A fundamental rule of the legislative process is that all deliberations must be conducted in public, with public input, and based on documents that must be available to the public.  In past years, and especially in 2015, the process did not meet this standard.  The letter from MFOIC urges legislative leadership to avoid a repeat of this problem, and to take steps to ensure that the public is never again shut out of our legislature during key deliberations and decisions.

The text of the MFOIC letter is below.


MFOICLogoPO Box 232, Augusta, Maine 04332


December 16, 2015


The Honorable Michael Thibodeau, President of the Senate

The Honorable Mark Eves, Speaker of the House

The Honorable Justin Alfond, Maine State Senate

The Honorable Kenneth Fredette, Maine House of Representatives

The State House

Augusta, Maine 04330


Dear Legislative Leaders:

As the 127th Legislature prepares to convene for its second regular session, I write on behalf of the Maine Freedom of Information Coalition’s Board of Directors to lodge a concern about the closed-door budget talks that ended the first regular session in June.

It was an affront to Maine residents to craft a budget in private and refuse to allow members of the public to view the document until after it had been approved by the Legislature. The process was grossly contrary to all sense of transparency and accountability, and a clear deviation from the Legislature’s Joint Rules that places sole decision-making authority on budget matters squarely with the Joint Standing Committee on Appropriations and Financial Affairs — not with legislative leadership.

The excuse that these are “not normal times” in Augusta does not authorize an abnormal budget process, and the closed-door negotiations were anything but “tweaks.” The outcome changed Maine’s tax code without public hearing or debate, among other things, favoring the convenience of private talks over the valued trust that grows from discourse conducted in full public view.

The episode was so revolting to Mal Leary, a founding member of MFOIC, that he resigned his appointment on the Legislature’s Right to Know Advisory Committee in protest. At the time, this much-respected journalist and public access advocate made a clear point to withdraw himself from his legislative appointment because he didn’t want to have anything to do with a “process that excludes the public from even knowing about the proposed changes in laws that affect them.”

So, in the early days of the upcoming session, the MFOIC implores you individually and collectively to amend the Joint Rules to specifically ban closed-door meetings for budget negotiations — in conformance with Maine’s Freedom of Access Act and your own Joint Rules — to ensure such an episode is not repeated. We suggest the following language be added to Joint Rule 304: “All hearings, work sessions and other meetings of committees, and subcommittees thereof, shall be open to the public.”

Very truly yours,


Suzanne D. Goucher, President, MFOIC

President & CEO, Maine Association of Broadcasters

For the Board of Directors of the Maine Freedom of Information Coalition:

Mal Leary, Maine Pro Chapter, Society of Professional Journalists

Judy Meyer, Maine Press Association

Jim Campbell, Maine Library Association

Jim Henderson, representing government/academic interests

Jon Brautigam, League of Women Voters of Maine

Rachel Healy, American Civil Liberties Union of Maine

Sig Schutz, Esq., Preti Flaherty



The Honorable Garrett P. Mason

The Honorable Andre E. Cushing III

The Honorable Dawn Hill

The Honorable Jeff McCabe

The Honorable Sara Gideon

The Honorable Ellie Espling


One thought on “State Budget Deliberations Must Be Open and Transparent

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s